The Fanciulli Is the Manhattan's More Bitter, Herbal Cousin

The Manhattan has earned its place as one of the defining whiskey cocktails, but the Fanciulli demonstrates how changing a single ingredient can create an entirely different drinking experience.

The formula begins with whiskey and sweet vermouth, two ingredients that have worked together in American cocktail culture for generations. Instead of finishing the combination with the aromatic bitters typically associated with a Manhattan, the Fanciulli introduces Fernet-Branca.

That substitution changes the drink considerably.

Fernet-Branca is an Italian amaro with an assertive herbal character. Its bitterness, spice and cooling qualities can transform a cocktail even when used sparingly. In the Fanciulli, a quarter ounce is enough to give the whiskey and vermouth a more pronounced herbal finish.

The cocktail is generally associated with the early twentieth century, and its name has been linked to Francesco Fanciulli, a former director of the United States Marine Band. The historical connection is intriguing, although the exact circumstances of the drink's creation remain uncertain.

For bartenders, the choice between bourbon and rye provides another opportunity to shape the drink.

Bourbon brings a rounder sweetness that can soften Fernet's bitterness. Rye emphasizes spice and creates a more assertive finish. Neither approach requires changing the proportions.

This is also a useful reminder that classic cocktail development does not always require elaborate techniques or additional ingredients. A carefully chosen modifier can completely change a familiar formula.

The Fanciulli is especially appropriate for an evening aperitif or a later brunch that includes rich, savory dishes. Its herbal character can stand alongside aged cheeses, cured meats and roasted mushrooms.

For anyone who enjoys a Manhattan but wants something with a more bitter edge, the Fanciulli deserves consideration.

Recipe by Dylan Garret for Liquor.com

RECIPE:

2 oz bourbon or rye whiskey
3/4 oz sweet vermouth
1/4 oz Fernet-Branca

Method:

  1. Fill a mixing glass with ice.

  2. Add the whiskey, sweet vermouth and Fernet-Branca.

  3. Stir for approximately 15 to 20 seconds until thoroughly chilled.

  4. Strain into a chilled coupe and serve.

https://www.liquor.com/fanciulli-cocktail-recipe-8385983

Next
Next

Improved Whiskey Cocktail